On the other end, I have been very pleased with the Apple case. It is has been dropped numerous times with the apple case on, even on concrete, with zero cracks or issues. Make sure you get a good screen protector (impact kind) and keep your phone at a reasonable size.
I have a lot of friends that love the otterbox, in fact, my work issues them with out phones. I personally can't stand them. I can't comfortably keep my phone in my pocket with that huge rubber case, they never stay clean, and I don't like the plastic protector over the screen. Just my 0.02.
So many good cases on amazon that you can certainly find one that meets your liking.