So, I decided to go back to 1966, the year I was born. All this "record setting cold" is far from it... it's just record setting for this year so far. If anything, today's temperature of 11 (low) to 14 (high) is pretty normal. At least around here.

The coldest day of 1966 was January 28, with a low temperature of 6°F.
The coldest day of 1967 was February 9, with a low temperature of 4°F.
The coldest day of 1968 was January 12, with a low temperature of 3°F.
The coldest day of 1969 was January 1, with a low temperature of 13°F.
The coldest day of 1970 was January 9, with a low temperature of -1°F.
The coldest day of 1971 was February 2, with a low temperature of 4°F.
The coldest day of 1972 was January 16, with a low temperature of 5°F.
The coldest day of 1973 was February 17, with a low temperature of 10°F.
The coldest day of 1974 was November 25, with a low temperature of 1°F.
The coldest day of 1975 was February 10, with a low temperature of 11°F.
The coldest day of 1976 was January 23, with a low temperature of 1°F.
The coldest day of 1977 was January 17, with a low temperature of -3°F.
The coldest day of 1978 was February 10, with a low temperature of 4°F.
The coldest day of 1979 was February 18, with a low temperature of -5°F.
The coldest day of 1980 was December 25, with a low temperature of 4°F.
The coldest day of 1981 was January 12, with a low temperature of -2°F.
The coldest day of 1982 was January 17, with a low temperature of -9°F.
The coldest day of 1983 was December 25, with a low temperature of -7°F.
The coldest day of 1984 was January 22, with a low temperature of -12°F.
The coldest day of 1985 was January 21, with a low temperature of -13°F.
The coldest day of 1986 was January 15, with a low temperature of 10°F.
The coldest day of 1987 was January 28, with a low temperature of 2°F.
The coldest day of 1988 was January 11, with a low temperature of 3°F.
The coldest day of 1989 was December 22, with a low temperature of 5°F.
The coldest day of 1990 was February 26, with a low temperature of 10°F.
The coldest day of 1991 was January 22, with a low temperature of 14°F.
The coldest day of 1992 was January 19, with a low temperature of 12°F.
The coldest day of 1993 was February 7, with a low temperature of 5°F.
The coldest day of 1994 was January 19, with a low temperature of -5°F.
The coldest day of 1995 was February 6, with a low temperature of 5°F.
The coldest day of 1996 was February 5, with a low temperature of 2°F.
The coldest day of 1997 was January 19, with a low temperature of 6°F.
The coldest day of 1998 was December 26, with a low temperature of 14°F.
The coldest day of 1999 was January 2, with a low temperature of 13°F.
The coldest day of 2000 was January 28, with a low temperature of 7°F.
The coldest day of 2001 was January 23, with a low temperature of 13°F.
The coldest day of 2002 was December 7, with a low temperature of 12°F.
The coldest day of 2003 was January 18, with a low temperature of 7°F.
The coldest day of 2004 was January 10, with a low temperature of 4°F.
The coldest day of 2005 was January 28, with a low temperature of 2°F.
The coldest day of 2006 was February 19, with a low temperature of 14°F.
The coldest day of 2007 was January 26, with a low temperature of 10°F.
The coldest day of 2008 was February 11, with a low temperature of 12°F.
The coldest day of 2009 was January 17, with a low temperature of 6°F.
The coldest day of 2010 was February 7, with a low temperature of 11°F.
(2011 was unreported on the source I was using)
The coldest day of 2012 was December 24, with a low temperature of 24°F.
The coldest day of 2013 was January 23, with a low temperature of 11°F.