What type of riding are you looking for?
For twisty asphalt, Southwest Wisconsin would fare higher on my list than Laramie WY.
My thoughts for asphalt + twisty + scenery near Laramie
1) Laramie WY to Yellowstone / Jackson WY / Beartooth Highway = 6+ hours of open space (straights with wide eyes horizon open) between Laramie and Jackson WY / Cody WY
2) Laramie to Custer SD = ~4 hours
3) Laramie to Grandby Colorado - (not stellar in itself - but a somewhat central point for north central CO roads??) = 2.5 hours
How about Montrose CO, Salida CO, Custer SD, Cody WY?